Almost one in three business leaders (31%) say they are “put off” by the ESG claims of companies who over-promote their environmental and social initiatives.
Efforts by some firms to promote their improved impact on society are pushing some customers away and risk damaging their reputation, according to public relations and ESG communications agency, Clearly PR.
Managing director Paul MacKenzie-Cummins, said: “ESG has been catapulted to the top of the business agenda over the last three years. The transition of conscious consumerism from being a ‘moment’ to becoming a ‘movement’ has sparked a rise in post-pandemic purpose-led businesses.
“While this is to be welcomed, the extent to which many businesses are talking about their ESG credentials has become frenzied. This is clearly alienating many customers and negatively impacting the perception that their target market has of these businesses.
“There is, it seems, too much banging on the green and purpose drum and there is evidence to suggest that customers view excessive ESG communications as hyperbole rather than authentic. As such, in many cases they have either become immune to the ESG messaging emanating from businesses or distrusting of their validity.”
Subscribe to Sustainability Beat for free
Sign up here to get the latest sustainability news sent straight to your inbox everyday
Some 31% of the organisational leaders surveyed said they were “put off” a business that talks a lot about its ESG initiatives in the press and on social media, as these businesses turn up the dial on ESG to be heard above the noise.
More than a third (36%) said that such messages and communications had “no effect” on them whatsoever, while just under 17% said they questioned the validity of ESG claims made by these businesses.
Only 16% said that they look more favourably on those who regularly share updates on their environmental and social responsibility initiatives.
Clearly PR, which became a B Corp in 2021, believes that businesses doing ‘good’ for people and planet should be vocal about it, but in moderation and to the right audience.
“Sharing regular stories about ESG initiatives to an equally invested audience is OK, but flooding all communication channels with this messaging won’t wash with those customers with little or no interest in what a business does for the good of the environment and society,” added MacKenzie-Cummins.
“All [customers] want to know is how the business’s products or services can address their needs and wants.
“Businesses should focus their messaging primarily on what they do, while the ‘purpose’ element is the added value of doing business with them – not the primary reason for it. The conscious consumer will seek out this added value.”
